Scotto's Italian deli & meat market
Edit📍 25 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY
Average Score
8.9
Slice Style Ratings
Visit History
Margherita — 2026-08-28
“The pizza today from Scotto’s had too much cheese. Even though their cheese is some of the best cheese I have ever had, there was just too much today. Otherwise the rest of the pizza was sold as always. ”
New York — 2026-05-23
“This slice is very good. The cheese at Scotto’s is top notch. The only reason foldability is so low is because of how the hot the slice was so the cheese just fell off. ”
Grandma — 2026-05-23
“The grandma slice is terrific. The make their own fresh mozzarella and it shows. ”
Margherita — 2026-05-23
“This is the best slice they offer. The cheese is mouthwatering. The crust is in the Goldilocks zone, not to soft but not to crunchy. It’s pretty close to a perfect slice ”